Maybe I shouldn't be posting here as I'm not ruling the case, but let me just state my opinion. We're not talking about the Dulcite case because that ban has been ruled invalid. As a result, Dulcite was removed from the staff. What makes you think we're intentionally keeping you banned for no reason? We're interested in more players coming, you know. The reason your IP was banned is because it belonged to a player who was caught hacking by the staff. There is no way for someone to use your account AND IP address UNLESS they have your router password (in case of Wi-Fi) or are using your very PC, AND your MSR account password. You, and you only, are responsible for your Wi-Fi password, your computer and your account. So the ban IS very valid.
But I'm still thinking of coming up with a rule for the staff to have some sort of evidence of players breaking rules. At least I do try to back all my bans up with a sort of a screen or a Fraps video, or talk to other admins to discuss whether a player is hacking.